1. Honestly, what the heck was going on with Mr. Antolini? Like was he just drunk or did he have like....a crush on him? So confusing yet no closure?
2. Do you think the last two conversation with Phoebe were the most integral parts of the book?
3. What changed in Holden at the carousel?
4. Why does Phoebe want to go with Holden so bad if he has not really been that nice to her?
5. Do you think after this Holden kind of let go of Allie and is finally beginning to live his life and get closer to Phoebe?